Similarities and differences between J1939 and NMEA 2000
The world of communication protocols for marine and automotive systems can be confusing. Two protocols that share similar characteristics are J1939 and NMEA 2000. In this article, we will explore the differences and similarities between the two protocols and help you decide which one is the best fit for your needs.
Understanding J1939 and NMEA 2000
What is J1939?
J1939 is a communication protocol used primarily in the heavy-duty vehicle and marine industries. It is a CAN-based protocol that provides a standardized way for electronic devices to communicate with each other over a network. J1939 is an essential part of modern heavy-duty vehicles and marine vessels, as it enables different electronic systems to communicate with each other seamlessly. This communication allows for better control and monitoring of the vehicle or vessel, leading to improved safety and efficiency.
The J1939 protocol specifies how messages are transmitted between electronic devices, including the message format, message timing, and message priority. It also defines how devices can identify themselves on the network and how they can request information from other devices. This standardization ensures that devices from different manufacturers can communicate with each other, regardless of the specific implementation details.
What is NMEA 2000?
NMEA 2000 is a communication protocol used in the marine industry. It is also a CAN-based protocol that provides a standardized way for electronic devices to communicate with each other over a network. NMEA 2000 was created by the National Marine Electronics Association to simplify and improve the way marine electronics communicate with each other.
NMEA 2000 is an essential part of modern marine vessels, as it enables different electronic systems to communicate with each other seamlessly. This communication allows for better control and monitoring of the vessel, leading to improved safety and efficiency. NMEA 2000 is used to connect a wide variety of devices, including GPS systems, depth sounders, fish finders, and more.
The NMEA 2000 protocol specifies how messages are transmitted between electronic devices, including the message format, message timing, and message priority. It also defines how devices can identify themselves on the network and how they can request information from other devices. This standardization ensures that devices from different manufacturers can communicate with each other, regardless of the specific implementation details.
Key Similarities between J1939 and NMEA 2000
When it comes to communication protocols, J1939 and NMEA 2000 are two of the most commonly used protocols in the automotive and marine industries. While these protocols have some differences, they also share a number of key similarities that make them both reliable and effective solutions for transmitting data between devices.
Network Architecture
One of the key similarities between J1939 and NMEA 2000 is their use of a bus network architecture. This architecture allows multiple devices to be connected on a single network, which reduces wiring and makes it easier to install new devices. This type of network architecture is particularly useful in large vehicles or vessels, where there may be many different systems that need to be connected and communicate with each other.
Communication Protocols
Another similarity between J1939 and NMEA 2000 is their use of a CAN-based communication protocol. This protocol is reliable and provides error detection and correction mechanisms, which help to ensure that data is transmitted accurately and without errors. The CAN-based protocol also allows for a high volume of data to be transmitted quickly, which is important in applications where real-time data is critical.
Data Transmission Speeds
Both J1939 and NMEA 2000 support data transmission speeds of up to 1 Mbps. This allows for a high volume of data to be transmitted quickly, which is essential in applications where real-time data is critical. The high-speed data transmission also helps to ensure that data is transmitted accurately and without errors, which is important in applications where data accuracy is crucial.
Error Detection and Handling
Both J1939 and NMEA 2000 have error detection and handling mechanisms that allow for reliable communication between devices. These mechanisms ensure that any errors are detected and corrected in real-time, preventing data loss or system failure. This is particularly important in applications where data accuracy and system reliability are critical.
Key Differences between J1939 and NMEA 2000
When it comes to communication protocols, J1939 and NMEA 2000 are two of the most widely used in their respective industries. While they share some similarities, there are several key differences that set them apart. Let’s take a closer look at these differences and how they impact device compatibility and system performance.
Application Areas
As mentioned, J1939 is primarily used in the heavy-duty vehicle industry, while NMEA 2000 is used in the marine industry. However, there are some areas where the two protocols overlap. For example, J1939 is commonly used in marine applications such as large commercial vessels and offshore oil rigs.
One of the reasons for the different application areas is the environmental conditions that the devices are exposed to. Heavy-duty vehicles operate in harsh environments with high levels of vibration, while marine devices must be able to withstand saltwater corrosion and extreme temperature fluctuations.
Message Formats and Parameter Group Numbers (PGNs)
Another key difference between J1939 and NMEA 2000 is the way they format messages and use parameter group numbers (PGNs). J1939 uses PGNs to define and structure data transmission, while NMEA 2000 groups messages into functional categories.
For example, in J1939, a PGN might be used to transmit data related to engine speed, while in NMEA 2000, data related to engine speed might be grouped with other engine-related data in a single message. This difference in message formats and PGNs can affect the way data is exchanged between devices and must be taken into account when designing a system.
Connector Types and Cabling
Another important difference between J1939 and NMEA 2000 is the type of connectors and cabling used. J1939 uses Deutsch connectors that are common in the heavy-duty vehicle industry, while NMEA 2000 uses Micro-C connectors that are designed for the harsh marine environment.
These differences in connector types and cabling can affect device compatibility and installation. For example, if a marine device with a Micro-C connector needs to be connected to a heavy-duty vehicle with a J1939 connector, an adapter or converter may be required.
To summarise…
While there are some differences between J1939 and NMEA 2000, they share a number of key similarities that make them both reliable and effective communication protocols. These similarities include their use of a bus network architecture, a CAN-based communication protocol, high-speed data transmission capabilities, and robust error detection and handling mechanisms. By understanding these similarities, engineers and technicians can make informed decisions about which protocol to use in their specific application.
To learn more about the features and benefits of the NMEA 2000 protocol, read our article here.
For more on building and testing your NMEA 2000 network, read our article here.
What is CAN Bus and how does it work? 
3 fundamentals of designing a fault free NMEA 2000 network 
How do I build a hybrid NMEA 0183 and NMEA 2000 network?